Ended up fishing Turtle on Friday as I got done with work early and it is right next to my house. Was a dead sea, only had a couple marks and caught one tiny perch. Fished Island on Saturday and got some good gills and crappies fishing far away from others. When someone started plowing around 3, the bite completely shut off. Went back out today to give it a try and it was really slow with all the activity on the lake.
Remember, the most important thing you can give is your time.